Architecture of Unions: Balancing and bandwagoning in international relations

From Metaphor to Concept: The Balance of Power in Hans Morgenthau's Classical Realism

The concept of balance of power is one of the central and at the same time the most controversial in the theory of international relations. In its most general form, it refers to a distribution of power between States in which no one actor has sufficient superiority to impose its will on others. However, this simple formulation hides a complex theoretical construction that has undergone significant evolution. The question of whether the balance of power is a conscious policy of States, an objective law of the system, or an analytical metaphor remains a matter of debate. The purpose of this article is to trace how the understanding of the balance of power and the related concept of polarity changed during the transition from classical realism to structural analysis, and to show that this change was not just terminological, but conceptual in nature.

Classical realism, most fully represented in the works of Hans Morgenthau, proceeds from the understanding of international politics as a continuous struggle for power. In this paradigm, the balance of power is neither an institution nor a consciously constructed mechanism, but the result of the interaction of States, each of which pursues its own national interest, defined in terms of power. Morgenthau's key theoretical framework is built around the concepts of strength, balance of power, and national interest, defined in terms of power. The balance of power in this interpretation is a specific expression of the general social principle, according to which the stability of any system consisting of independent units is ensured by the mutual balancing of their potentials. Morgenthau emphasized that stability achieved through a balance of power is, by definition, fragile and requires constant adjustments, since any change in the distribution of power immediately upsets the balance.

This understanding of the balance of power is based on a certain anthropology and methodological individualism: the source of international dynamics is recognized as the nature of a person striving for power, and the unit of analysis is a separate state making foreign policy decisions. States are considered as rational actors who, in the absence of supreme power (anarchy), are forced to influence their own forces. It is this starting point -anarchy as a fundamental property of the international environment — that becomes the starting point for subsequent criticism and reformulation of realistic theory. However, in classical realism, anarchy is not yet a structural concept in the strict sense: rather, it acts as a common background against which the interaction of selfish states unfolds. The balance of power here is the result of their rational strategies, not a property of the system as such.

The limitations of this approach become apparent when trying to explain stable patterns of international behavior that are not limited to individual decisions of government leaders. If the balance of power is an excess product of rational choice, then why are some configurations of forces more stable than others? Why do States with different internal regimes and ideologies exhibit similar patterns of behavior under similar structural conditions? The answer to these questions required shifting the level of analysis from the individual and the State to the international system as a whole.

Kenneth Waltz's "Structural Revolution": The System Level and Microeconomic Logic

This conceptual turn took shape in 1979 with the publication of Kenneth Waltz's fundamental work “Theory of International Politics. Sam Waltz consistently referred to his approach as ”structural realism,“ while the term ”neorealism" was largely adopted by academic critics. The fundamental difference from the classical tradition was a change in the level of analysis: if Morgenthau derived international dynamics from the nature of man and the behavior of individual states, then Waltz proposed to consider the international system as an independent reality with its own structure, which imposes restrictions on the actions of all actors, regardless of their internal characteristics. The methodological basis of the theory was not structural and functional sociological analysis, and certainly not European structuralism, but a strict analogy with microeconomics (neoclassical market theory): Just as the market is spontaneously formed by competing firms and then dictates the rules of the game to them, the anarchic structure of the international system arises from the interaction of states, but it severely restricts their foreign policy choices.

Balance of power as a rational strategy on the global chessboard

The structure of the international system, according to Waltz, is determined by three elements. The first is the principle of order, which in international politics is anarchy, understood not as chaos, but as the absence of supreme authority over States. The second is the functional similarity of units: states, unlike actors within a country, perform single tasks related to ensuring sovereignty and security, and cannot specialize in something else. The third and most mobile element is the distribution of opportunities between units. The opportunities themselves belong to individual States, but their distribution is a property of the system. It is the nature of this distribution that sets the structure, while anarchy and functional similarity remain relatively stable in the long run. In conditions of anarchy, States are forced to rely on their own strength, which generates a stable mutual distrust and pushes them to continuously strengthen their positions relative to each other. Mutual balancing keeps the system from sliding into chaos - through building up its own capabilities or through alliances against threats. Thus, the balance of power in structural realism ceases to be the result of conscious politics and turns into a systemic mechanism that naturally follows from anarchy and the struggle for survival.

The Architecture of polarity: the stability dilemma of bipolar and multipolar orders

It is within the framework of this logic that the concept of polarity is formed, which was used rather descriptively in classical realism, and acquired analytical rigor in structural analysis. The polarity is determined by the number of major powers in the system and the relative distribution of forces between them. Two major powers give bipolarity, three or more give multipolarity. In this case, the polarity and the balance of forces are not identical: the balance of forces reflects the relative distribution of power, while the polarity captures the quantitative and structural characteristics of the system. In bipolar systems, balance is achieved directly and clearly, in multipolar systems, the distribution of power is more complex and mobile, and in unipolar systems, power is pulled together to a clear hegemon with weak balancing mechanisms. Waltz's definition of polarity became a model within the realist tradition.

Multipolar configuration: dispersal of power centers

The relationship between polarity and stability of the system has become one of the most controversial issues. Waltz argued for the absolute superiority of a bipolar structure over a multipolar one, in which the risk of strategic miscalculations increases dramatically due to the complexity of coalitions. Within the framework of structural realism, unipolarity is interpreted not just as problematic, but as the least durable structure: systemic anarchy inevitably pushes other players to counterbalance against the hegemon. The logic of this conclusion was based on the idea that in a bipolar system there is clarity about the interests of the enemy and the means at his disposal, which reduces the risk of miscalculation. In multipolarity, external balancing is the dominant strategy, as there are more polar states and a more balanced distribution of opportunities between them. However, flexibility hides rigidity: as each state depends more on others, obligations to allies increase, and an increase in their number leads to the risk of miscalculation. That is why multipolar structures are assessed as less stable. However, this position is not generally accepted: subsequent studies have shown that the stability of multipolar structures depends not so much on their internal logic as on the scarcity or excess of resources needed to enhance the capabilities of polar states, as well as on specific historical conditions.

Differentiation of realism: Neoclassical synthesis, bandwagoningand threat balance

Further development of the theory was associated with attempts to overcome the limitations of structural realism, which became especially evident after the end of the Cold War. Structural realism, initially based on the postulate of the stability of the bipolar order, faced a crisis of explanatory possibilities, since the collapse of the USSR was poorly correlated with structural causes, and Waltz's theory consistently avoided analyzing the internal characteristics of states, considering them as unitary actors. In addition, critics pointed out that structural realism is unable to determine at what point the structure has a deterministic effect on the elements, and at what point the reverse process is observed. These methodological difficulties stimulated the formation of neoclassical realism, which claims to have a holistic research program that included arguments from both classical and structural realism and responded to criticism from competing approaches.

Neoclassical realism, the term for which was coined by G. Rose in 1998, complemented neorealism with various levels of analysis, linking the international structure with the state and sub-state levels. In this model, the independent variable is primarily a material indicator of the relative power of the state in the existing structure of international relations, which determines the scale and ambitions of foreign policy. The variable is the substate level, which includes the political system, institutions, perceptions of political elites, ideology, and culture. The dependent variable, in turn, is the result of the convergence of the first two levels, expressed in a specific foreign policy. The fundamental difference from neorealism is that neoclassicists do not limit the number of internal correction variables and do not consider polarity as a rigid and unambiguous characteristic of the system.: They argue that the types of polarity described by the neorealists are practically unattainable in reality, and the system may unnecessarily strive for them, which makes it possible to analyze transition states when the system moves from one type to another. In addition, neoclassical realism draws attention to the policy of "following the fairway", or bandwagoning (joining the strongest side), emphasizing that for many small and medium—sized states it is she who has a regular character, and not a policy of balance of power.

In parallel with the neoclassical trend, other branches developed within the realistic tradition. Stephen Walt's defensive realism, whose concept of threat balance became the development of the theory of balance of power, emphasized that states balance not so much against power as against threats emanating from specific actors. John Mearsheimer's offensive realism, for example, returned realism to the "pessimistic" or "Hobbesian" nature of interstate interaction, insisting that in conditions of unclear intentions of other players, the most rational strategy is to constantly build up one's own power; in this logic, the balance of power is permanently confrontational and does not provide lasting stability, and the solution is seen in the creation of local balance sheet systems. However, even this scheme did not explain the complex behavior of small and medium-sized states, reducing their strategies either to balancing or to joining a stronger player. Thus, the realistic tradition did not remain monolithic: it differentiated into a number of directions, each of which in its own way redefined the relationship of structure, balance of forces and polarity.

Conclusion

Modern discussions about polarity have gone beyond the classical realistic scheme. The concept of polarity, which was initially systematically developed in Waltz's work, continues to be an analytical tool, but its application to the post-bipolar world has raised a number of new questions. If structural realism considered unipolarity as a temporary and internally unstable state, since the establishment of hierarchy in an anarchic system should cause a natural balancing reaction, then empirical observations of the late twentieth and early twenty–first centuries showed that such a reaction does not always take the form of classical external balancing. Since the 1990s, the number of papers on the weakening of American dominance and the changing balance of power has steadily increased, and most scientists agree that the modern world order is at the stage of structural transformation. At the same time, the question of which configuration the system is moving towards — a new bipolarity, multipolarity, or continued unipolarity with elements of power dispersion — remains debatable. The discussion on the relationship between polarity and stability, initiated within the framework of structural realism, has thus not been completed, and the conceptual framework itself, developed within the framework of the realistic tradition, continues to be used to analyze transitional periods, even if its explanatory capabilities are recognized as limited. The evolution of approaches from classical realism to structural analysis and further to neoclassical and other branches shows that the central problem of balance of forces and polarity has not disappeared, but has only acquired a more complex and multidimensional form, reflecting both the complexity of the object of research and the development of methodological tools for its analysis.

Tags: Theory of international relations, balance of forces, polarity, classical realism, structural realism, neorealism, neoclassical realism, Kenneth Waltz, Hans Morgenthau, bipolarity, multipolarity, anarchy of the international system, bandwagoning, transformation of the world order, great powers